John Atkinson, in several posts on the topic of subjective testing in another post, has presented arguments so void of logic that I must respond. In this comparison of medical, wine, and other blind testing to audio, he wrote, "[The item] being tested is the direct effect of the stimulus. With audio, you must test the stimulus indirectly, through its effect on music." He then goes on to talk about test signals and other issues that can only lead to a reasonable response of,