Records 2 Live 4 2024 Page 4


Kurt Gottschalk


Kate Bush: The Dreaming
EMI America ST-17084 (LP). 1983. Kate Bush, prod.; Ron McMaster, eng.

Kate Bush's true masterpiece has lived in the shadows of its successor for four decades, a fate worsened by the resurgence last year of the later album's "Running Up That Hill." The tribal drumming and Fairlight synth were there on The Dreaming's opening and title tracks, without the believe-in-yourself messaging. Instead, we get a thirst for knowledge and an Australian automobile accident. Elsewhere, there's bank robbers and magicians, not to mention a haunted house in the album's truly terrifying closer. It's manic, chaotic, controlled, and very musical. There's no album quite like it.

David Bowie: [Blackstar]
Columbia 88875173862, ISO Records 88875173862 (CD). 2016. David Bowie, Tony Visconti, prods.; Erin Tonkon, Kabir Hermon, Kevin Killen, Tony Visconti, engs.

When I heard the news of David Bowie's death, I had already streamed the album he released a few days earlier a half-dozen times. I'm forever glad for the certainty that my take on his swan song isn't tainted by sentiment: I was already convinced of its genius. Blackstar is both harrowing and full of love. I like long songs and monochrome sets, and the darkness of Blackstar really only compares to the Thin White Duke of Station to Station, my other favorite of his records. Both are bold dramas about moving between worlds.


Larry Greenhill


Rising W/The Crossing
International Contemporary Ensemble, Kevin Vondrak; The Crossing, Donald Nally; Quicksilver; John Greca, keyboards; Edward Babcock, marimba
New Focus Recordings FCR281 (CD). 2020. Paul Vazquez, Donald Nally, Kevin Vondrak, prods.; Vazquez, eng.

The Crossing is a Philadelphia-based choral group, and The Rising refers to their effort to fill the void during the pandemic's Great Shutdown, when they were unable to perform. Donald Nally, the group's director, sent a digital music file from their archive of live recordings to friends and fellow musicians every sunrise (in Philadelphia) for two weeks, which explains the album's title. The standout track for me is Eriks Ešenvalds's "Earth Teach Me Quiet," with words from a Ute prayer. The Crossing delivers Ešenvalds's layered vocals suffused with reverence, calm, and a haunting quality that fills me with sadness. David Lang's "National Anthems: I. Our Land With Peace" wrapped me in intimate vocals, not the usual national-anthem bombast. "Protect yourself from infection" opens the album; it's a sardonic piece that blends Lang's solemn, religious music with words from a 1918 government document undercut by soloists reading the names of Philadelphians who died from influenza despite the advice. The effect makes the album inspiring, uplifting, and very special.


Alex Halberstadt


Sonny Rollins: Sonny Rollins (Sometimes Known As Sonny Rollins Vol.1)
Blue Note BLP-1542 (LP). 1957. Alfred Lion, prod.; Rudy Van Gelder, eng.

In the 1950s, Sonny Rollins made a string of records that showcased his relentlessly original improvisation in solos that seemed incapable of sounding obvious for even a measure. Among these LPs were a handful of masterpieces. This eponymous session for Blue Note isn't one of them. It happens, however, to be a perfect record. Rollins made greater artistic statements but never a greater stylistic one. What Volume 1 demonstrates better than the others is the density of tone he could bring out of the saxophone as well as the hard-boiled economy of his phrasing, which finds its truest analogs in the laconic prose of writers like William Maxwell and James M. Cain. Rollins's playing here has no false or extra notes, no showy runs, no vulgarity. As Cain wrote in The Postman Only Rings Twice, "the devil got his money's worth that night."

Lou Reed: Berlin
RCA Victor APL1-0207 (LP). 1973. Bob Ezrin, prod.; Peter Flanagan, Robin Black, Randy Kling, others, engs.

There's an uneasy ambiguity in much of Lou Reed's solo work that may be its defining feature. The music teeters between banality and flashes of genius. The lyrics embody a perverse interest in transgression as well as visceral anguish. This is no place for listeners looking for consistency and polish. Berlin is the record that captures these extremes most acutely. An orchestral rock cabaret, it follows a doomed couple named Caroline and Jim through episodes of spousal battery, addiction, prostitution, child abuse, and suicide so ghoulish that the whole thing skates on the edge of parody. Yet these episodes are shot through with vivid writing, tar-black humor, and glimpses of ravishing beauty. The musical settings encompass everything from arena rock and prog soundscapes to musique concrète. One of those albums that evolve in the mind with each subsequent listen, Berlin never gets easier. Reed may have been on to something when he said, "Maybe listening to my music is not the best idea if you live a very constricted life."


Andrey Henkin


Iron Maiden: Seventh Son Of A Seventh Son
Capitol C4-90258 (cassette). 1988. Martin Birch, prod., eng.

All of the phenomenal songcraft and long-form narrative found in earlier individual songs—"To Tame a Land," "Rime of the Ancient Mariner," and "Alexander the Great"—on Iron Maiden's previous three releases come together in its sole foray into the concept-album genre. Loosely inspired by Orson Scott Card's 1987 fantasy novel Seventh Son, this was the band's first nonlive recording that conveyed the epicness of an Iron Maiden concert. The title track is one of the finest compositions from bassist/bandleader/ main songwriter Steve Harris in the group's catalog, but it is the unusually collaborative process by which the album was written that makes it the band's most complete and successful effort.

John Abercrombie: Timeless
John Abercrombie, guitar, comp.; Jan Hammer, keyboards, comp.; Jack DeJohnette, drums
ECM 1047 (LP). 1974. Manfred Eicher, prod.; Tony May, eng.

This was the 43rd album from the still-new German label ECM. It was also John Abercrombie's debut as leader, the first of 28 albums he would make for the imprint until his 2017 death; alongside many sideman appearances, that makes him one of the label's most significant artists. The format of guitar, organ (Hammer, only six months removed from his time in the Mahavishnu Orchestra, also playing synthesizer and piano), and drums recalled Abercrombie's formative work in soul jazz.


Jon Iverson


El Búho: El Búho Live At Watdajel, Utrecht
YouTube. 2022. Self-produced, Self-released. bit.ly/ElBuhoLive

Yes, it's a video and yes, it's a deejay standing there pushing buttons and bouncing his head to the beats. You can ignore that part and just let the music run for an hour and a half. Recorded at the Watdajel festival in Utrecht, Netherlands, in late 2022, El Búho (Robin Perkins from England) creates much of this music in his studio and then mixes it live with other sources. In this set, his musical taste and skillful slicing and dicing of birdsong alongside Latin American acoustic and electronica is excellent. El Búho also has many wonderful studio albums on Bandcamp. I'm old enough to remember the best underground FM deejays artfully stringing tracks together in the '60s and '70s (we called them "segues" back then). In this video, the art of sequencing music has evolved further using the tech and broadcast media of today.

Myrkur: Folkesange
Relapse Records (16/44.1 Bandcamp download). 2020. Christopher Juul, prod., eng.

Myrkur (Amalie Brun) is renowned primarily as a Danish black-metal artist. This is not that Brun. There are no thrashing guitars and as far as I know, no references to the devil. Instead, she renders a modern spin on Nordic folk music using period acoustic instruments filtered via her metal sensibility. Evocative of dark Nordic winters, brief idyllic springtimes (depicted on the cover), and towering rocky cliffs, much of this album is somber—Myrkur is Icelandic for "darkness." Underpinned by a deep bass drum that punctuates the thrumming mandola, lyre, tagelharpa, and nyckelharpa, Amalie Brun's often-soaring voice alternates between sweet and severe just like the landscapes where these songs originate.


Anne E. Johnson


Stravinsky: Petrouchka (Complete)
Antal Doráti and Minnesota Symphony Orchestra
Mercury Living Presence SR90216 (LP). 1959. Wilma Cozart, prod.; C. Robert Fine, eng.

There are many great recordings of Petrouchka, but this one introduced me to the complete ballet, which remains one of my favorite 20th century pieces. Doráti approaches the recurring "Shrovetide Fair" theme with less seriousness than many conductors, recreating how the senses get overwhelmed in a crowded carnival atmosphere. There's delight and wonder, but always with a dark undertone.

Doráti had recorded the 1911 version of the ballet, also with Minnesota, four years previously. This is Stravinsky's 1947 version, using a slightly smaller orchestra and tweaking a few passages for trumpet and percussion. The most striking aspect of this later Doráti recording is the sound production. Wilma Cozart and C. Robert Fine, true to their Mercury Living Presence creed, captured a rich vibrancy from the MSO at Northrop Auditorium on the University of Minnesota campus. The orchestra's playing is tighter than on the 1955 attempt, which helps clarify the sound.

Various Artists: Rogue's Gallery: Pirate Ballads, Sea Songs, and Chanteys
Anti-Records 86817-2 (2 CDs). 2006. Hal Willner, prod.; Martin Brumbach, mixing.

When director Gore Verbinski and actor Johnny Depp were working on the second Pirates of the Caribbean movie, a side project developed. They hired record producer Hal Willner to put together a two-CD set of seafaring songs for Anti-Records. (They ended up with so many great tracks that some were later released as Son of Rogue's Gallery.) Besides the wonderful collection of rousing, rowdy, and heartrending songs, the lineup of talent is preposterous. Richard Thompson beckons the waves on "The Mingulay Boat Song." John C. Reilly contemplates the wisdom found from drinking. Rufus Wainwright and his mom, Kate McGarrigle, personify homesickness. In a pairing we didn't know we needed, Bryan Ferry and Antony (now known as Anohni) croon a haunting duet. Everything sung by Jack Shit would make a sailor blush. And then there are the tracks by Martin Carthy, Sting, Lou Reed, Bono, Jarvis Cocker, Van Dyke Parks, and on and on.

COMMENTS
jimtavegia's picture

I had put off long enough so an upgrade to my vinyl experience to a Technics SL-100C happened on Sunday, 1-21. After your Atmos story it was time to make my LP physical media sound its best. I changed out the AT-VM95C stylus that came with the table to the ML I just bought. So now between Tidal HD I can sort through all your recommendations and then buy the format I really want.

I still don't understand the reason for the lower rez Atmos deal. Most of us started our hi-fi journey with vinyl and now there is no reason to dismiss it now.

My youngest son now owns my Dual 501 table with a REGA RB250 arm and a AT-VM95E cart to start his vinyl journey.

Sal1950's picture

"I still don't understand the reason for the lower rez Atmos deal. Most of us started our hi-fi journey with vinyl and now there is no reason to dismiss it now."

Please, your way to intelligent to not "understand" Apples choice here. The file sizes of lossless Atmos files are huge and extremely demanding of expensive bandwidth, so made a compromise choice for financial reasons. But I do know you understand that perfectly.
Why do you not bash Spotify in any way for continuing to stream 2ch in a compressed form while most others have moved on?
Modern lossless high resolution multich from 5.1 to Atmos and Auro far exceeds the sound quality and enjoyment capability of 2ch.
I also started off my HiFi journey way back in the late 1950s and am so very excited and pleased with the progress we've made in the last 60+ years.
It's unfortunate your stuck on such primitive sources.

Sal1950's picture

"Lindberg has been at the forefront of producing immersive recordings—see above for the surround-sound formats in which this album is available—but since surviving the quadraphonic wars in the 1970s, I exclusively enjoy my recorded music in stereo. J.A."

John, Don't you think a 50 year grudge do to the weakness in 1970s technology is a bit long? Maybe you should get this "forefront" quality Atmos recording on BluRay, and a few more, then visit the new Atmos listening room Kal Rubinson has built. I'd say 50 years is long enough not to experience the progress the SOTA in home music reproduction has made. You might be enlightened.

SteveDisque's picture

John Atkinson hardly needs *me* to defend his choices. Still, why dismiss his attitude as a mere "grudge"? Multi-speaker sound systems are an elaborate nuisance to rig up (especially if you're as unmechanical or un-physical as I am), and definitely de trop in New York apartments and other smaller living spaces. (No question that the mutual incompatibility and misleading claims for the old quad systems didn't help.)

Like John, I just listen in frontal stereo. Yes, some labels are doing wonderful things in surround, but some aren't -- think of some of those late Pro Arte releases -- and I, for one, don't want to spend the time going down that rabbit hole. Just my $.02, or $.002.

Sal1950's picture

I don't know what else you can call it but a "grudge" when a man refuses to listen and explore new technology because of something that occurred 50 years ago ??? And this from a man that was supposed to be leading the readers of this magazine to the SOTA in music reproduction during much of that time. His predecessor (J. Gordon Holt) knew much better.
I know all about living in smaller spaces, living in a 900 sqft modular home, but I have a very good 5.2.4 multich/Atmos music reproduction system installed here.
When it comes to costs, a very large segment of this magazines readership consider $100,000 a entry level system, so many if not most, can well afford anything they desire.
---------------------------------------------
"Yes, some labels are doing wonderful things in surround, but some aren't -- think of some of those late Pro Arte releases"

Maybe if you spent more time listening to a quality surround system than typing, you'd have a more grounded understanding of the incredible amount and variety of TOTL quality multichannel recordings available in the world today.
cent' anni
Sal1950

lowtechphile's picture

Thanks for the tip on En Attendant Ana. I had not heard of this band. Lovely album.

barfle's picture

I teresting that there’s no Rick Wakeman on anyone’s list, or Beach Boys, or Holst’s “The Planets” or “1812 Overture.” There’s a lot of music there that helps make MY life worth living.

SteveDisque's picture

I'd merely point out that a recording of either "The Planets" or "1812" would have to be really special to qualify for "Records to Live/Die For." Back in LP days, the Steinberg/BSO "Planets" might readily have qualified; but the CD processing has betrayed it, making the silky BSO strings sound like a synthesizer. So *that* one's out....

Trevor_Bartram's picture

I enjoyed: En Attendant Ana, Principia with echoes of Stereolab circa Margerine Eclipse. Stravinsky, Petrushka an MLP sonic marvel on par with the Howard Hanson recordings. I look forward to the Kristy MacColl & June Tabor recordings. Thanks!

Lars Bo's picture

Thanks, Jim.

The 1991 Records To Die For, you mention, has another special significance to me - it gave the final push to buy my first CD player:

While visiting family in the U.S., who happened to have a recent SP-issue with R2D4 91, I read Gordon Emerson's recommendation of David Diamond Symphonies 2 & 4*. None of us knew much about the works of Diamond, but the description intrigued me, so I bought the CD. We ended up playing it a lot, and not to be able to play this music (especially the 2nd sym.) once back home in Denmark was a bleak outlook. Vinyl was also starting to get scarce, so at this point I simply decided to buy an inexpensive CD player, to get going.

My new player didn't really sound very good or convey play of music very well. Or stay for very long in my setup at the time. But, while not furthering high intensity experience, it did most importantly provide a gateway to more worlds of Music Magic.

*https://www.stereophile.com/content/1991-records-die-page-4

X