Analog Corner #195: Lejonklou, Soundsmith, Vad Lyd Phono Preamplifiers

The phono preamplifiers reviewed this month (footnote 1) are both affordable ($400–$1960) and highly accomplished. Three of them are designed to be used only with moving-magnet, moving-iron, and high-output moving-coil cartridges, so I installed Shure's V15VxMR cartridge in VPI's Classic 3 turntable (reviewed in this issue) and listened in MM mode to all of them, beginning with the least expensive.

Among the LPs used for this survey were: a double 45rpm reissue of Ella Fitzgerald's Ella Swings Lightly (Verve/ORG MG-VS 6019); AC/DC's Back in Black, remastered by George Marino and issued in a boxed set (Epic); and a stupendous 45rpm set of Falla's The Three-Cornered Hat, with Ernest Ansermet and L'Orchestre de la Suisse Romande (Decca/London/ORG 102). The Falla has everything: depth on a huge soundstage, three-dimensionality, and timbral richness. It opens with a stage full of castanets, shouting male voices, then a solo mezzo-soprano (Teresa Berganza) way in the distance, and strings, winds and brass.

Soundsmith MMP3
The MMP3 ($399.95) can be ordered directly from Soundsmith's website (footnote 2). It provides gain of 43dB, and can be special-ordered for 34dB. The noise spec is low, at –73dB. Input loading is the standard (though not always optimal) 47k ohms and 100pF capacitance. The MMP3 comes in a nicely machined aluminum case, and is powered by a 24V wall wart.

I didn't know the Soundsmith's price (I looked it up later), but it was clearly a relatively inexpensive product whose qualities were very quiet backgrounds and reasonably good dynamics. Its bass extension and punch were only moderately good, its imaging was somewhat diffuse, and its overall sound had a slight metallic overlay. The castanets in the Falla piece sounded more like metal than wood, the stage was reasonably wide but not particularly deep, and Berganza's voice sounded thin, the flutes shrill.

In short, no miracles—it's what you can expect for $400. If that's what you can afford, the MMP3 at least gets the job done quietly and cleanly. If you've got a really inexpensive phono preamp—say, an NAD or Audio-Technica—I wouldn't move up to the MMP3. I'd keep what I already had, and save up until I could afford to spend more than $400.

Lejonklou Kinki3 and Slipsik5.1
I received two MM-only phono preamps from a Swedish company whose name I keep mispronouncing as "Kinkajou." It's Lejonklou (footnote 3). They sent me two models, the Kinki3 and the KlausKinski. No, I take that back—it's the SlippeDiski. No, wait, lemme look: it's the Slipsik5.1!

I poke infantile fun at these preamps only because they sound exceptionally fine. They came in identical aluminum boxes, one black-anodized, one not (silver and gloss white are also available), hardwired with a relatively long AC cord with a molded plug.

When I listened to them I didn't know which was the more expensive, or even how much either of them cost, but both impressed me immediately, producing a smooth, midrange-rich sound with plenty of detail—but I thought the one in the dark case sounded more coherent overall, with fewer "edges" showing.

Both Lejonklous produced surprisingly credible, superbly refined renditions of the Falla recording, with excellent microdynamic expression and long, clean decays, expansive stages, the sweetness of the strings, a harmonic fullness of the brass that one usually associates with relatively pricey gear, and clean attacks that revealed the castanets' hollow wooden quality. The one in the darker case simply did all this better, while showing fewer electronic seams. Then I checked the prices.

I was genuinely surprised. The one in the dark case that sounded more complete and coherent was the Slipsik5.1 ($1595), but the Kinki3 ($895) came reasonably close, and was easily the best value of all of the products surveyed here (although, of course, it's MM only). The Kinki3 provides 40dB gain and fixed 47k ohms/80pF input loading. If you opt for a lower-output cartridge, you could always add an outboard step-up transformer.

But if you're seriously committed to high-output cartridges, whether MC, MM, or moving-iron, and if you can spend $1595, it's easy to recommend the Slipsik5.1 (41dB gain, 47k ohms/68pF). It may be the finest-sounding MM-only phono preamp I've heard. (The Gram Slee was my previous favorite.) And if $1595 is too much, it's easy to recommend the Kinki3. The Lejonklous don't look like much, but give them a listen and I think you'll be impressed.

Vad Lyd 78rpm and RIAA phono preamplifier
This phono preamp from Denmark (footnote 4) is easily the most versatile I've encountered. It includes a pair of inputs that can be configured for MM and MC operation, and equalization for 33.33rpm discs (RIAA, NAB, CCIR, ffrr LP 1953) as well as 78s (US30, Westrex, HMV, ffrr 1949, Decca, Columbia, BSI). It also can output flat (unequalized) response. In addition, its volume and balance controls let you drive an amplifier directly, and it has a headphone jack with its own volume control. It can also play vertically cut mono Pathé/Edison discs, and it can output the left and/or right channels monophonically. It has single-ended inputs and outputs, and two sets of balanced XLR outputs, one of which outputs, at all times, a flat, unequalized response. It also includes an 80Hz low-pass filter, and a high-pass filter that's continuously variable from 1.6 to 12kHz. In other words, it's an analog archivist's dream tool, and it's reasonably priced at $1960.

So, if you'd like to transfer those old 78s or Edison vertical cuts (I have a few), the Vad Lyd 78rpm and RIAA phono preamplifier allows you to do it. That said, for far less money you can transfer those discs using an Apple computer and Pure Vinyl software, and apply any of dozens of EQ curves in the digital domain. But if you're not interested in doing it in the digital domain, the Vad Lyd can do it in analog.

As an MM phono preamp using the RIAA curve, the Vad Lyd was okay but not great. Its sound wasn't as dynamic or as surgically precise as the Liberty Audio's, nor as liquid and fleshy as either of the Lejonklous. However, when I had the Shure V15VxMR mounted on the Kuzma 4Point arm and, using a 78rpm stylus, the Vad Lyd's EQ options and mono capabilities produced remarkably fine (old) sound from a collection of 78s by Ella Fitzgerald, Bing Crosby, and others that I've had for years. I even finally got to hear some thick, vertically cut Edison discs I'd never been able to play.

To keep it short: Unless you need the Vad Lyd's considerable archival flexibility, choose something else at this price point for the purest MM sound quality.

Switching to MC Mode
With a Lyra Helikon SL cartridge mounted on the tonearm of VPI's Classic 3 turntable, my first job was to listen through a known, reasonably priced phono preamp. I used Einstein Audio's Turntable's Choice ($5400). This combo produced finer detail and image resolution, and a noticeably wider and deeper soundstage, than did the Shure through any of the MM phono stages surveyed. The Lyra-VPI-Einstein's transparency, too, was far superior, but most noticeably better were the combo's textural and timbral delineation. For the most part, you pay more, you get more.

If you need the Vad Lyd 78rpm and RIAA's unique archival functionality, fine; otherwise, it painted a somewhat flat, hard picture populated with oversized images lacking in texture.

Soundsmith MCP2
Surprise! The Soundsmith MCP2 ($699.95), which offers 62dB of gain, continuously variable loading from 10 to 5k ohms, and has a noise floor of –75dB, is a winner! Its sins are of omission, and it reduces the quality of each performance parameter to a small but equal degree. Its midrange performance was on the slightly warm, enveloping side (I loaded the Lyra cartridge at 100 ohms); it produced a moderately wide, moderately deep soundstage; it had good, not great image size and three-dimensionality; it was reasonably dynamic; and its retrieval of detail was moderately good.

The MCP2's bass extension was fair but rhythmically lithe, and its overall smoothness made long listening sessions easy, so long as I didn't turn up the volume too far, at which point the sound turned a bit glary.

Quick Summary
The Soundsmith MCP2 is a much better buy at $699.95 than Soundsmith's MMP3 for $399.95. It can't compare to the Liberty B2B-1 that I also review in this issue, but at less than half the price, it's better than half as good!

The Lejonklous are both really fine MM phono preamps, and the Slipsik5.1 is among the best dedicated MM sections I've heard. I'd consider the Vad Lyd 78rpm and RIAA only if I needed the versatility, as sonically it was only okay; other, less expensive MM and MC models sounded considerably better.


Sidebar: In Heavy Rotation

1) Shostakovich, Piano Concerto 2 (Leonard Bernstein, piano, conductor; New York Philharmonic), Columbia/Impex 180gm LP

2) Hank Mobley, Another Workout, Blue Note/Music Matters 180gm 45rpm LPs (2)

3) Ella Fitzgerald & Duke Ellington, Ella & Duke at The Côte D'Azur, Verve/Mosaic 180gm LPs (3)

4) Marianne Faithfull, Strange Weather, Island/ORG 45rpm 180gm LPs (2)

5) Muddy Waters, Folk Singer, Chess/Analogue Productions 45rpm 180gm LPs (2)

6) Chuck Berry, St. Louis to Liverpool, Chess/Speakers Corner 180gm LP

7) Frank Sinatra, The Concert Sinatra, Reprise/Mobile Fidelity Sound Lab 180gm LP

8) Art Blakey, The Jazz Messengers, Columbia/Pure Pleasure 180gm LPs (2)

9) Laura Nyro, The First Songs, Columbia/Audio Fidelity 180gm LP

10) Pat Metheny, Day Trip/Tokyo Day Trip Live, Nonesuch 180gm LPs (3)


Footnote 1: Michael Fremer also reviewed the Liberty Audio B2B-1 and Precision Transducer Engineering (PTE) phono preamplifiers in this issue.—Ed.

Footnote 2: The Soundsmith, 2A John Walsh Blvd; Site 1 Bldg. Peekskill, NY 10566. Tel: (914) 739-2885. Email: Peter@sound-smith.com. Web: www.sound-smith.com.

Footnote 3: Firma Fredrik Lejonklou, Vänortsgatan 57, 752 64 Uppsala, Sweden. Tel: (46) 70-558-0549. Web: www.lejonklou.com. US distributor: Nokturne Audio, 8259 Hugh Street, Westland, MI 48185. Tel: (734) 612-4009. Web: www.nokturneaudio.com.

Footnote 4: Vad Lyd, Ballerupvej 46B, 3500 Vïrløse, Denmark. Tel: (45) 20267018. Email: md12@vadlyd.dk. Web: www.vadlyd.dk.

Advertisement
Advertisement
Advertisement